Why Staten Island Is One of New York’s Best Kept Secrets for Real Estate Investment

If you want NYC rental demand without Manhattan or Brooklyn price tags, Staten Island is worth a close look. Investors are finding a sweet spot of affordability, space, and steady appreciation—especially in neighborhoods near transit and the waterfront.

What Makes Staten Island Attractive for Investors

• Lower price per door compared to other boroughs
• Consistent rental demand from families and commuters
• Room to add value with light renovations or ADU-style improvements (where permitted)
• Community amenities and small-business growth

Neighborhoods to Watch

St. George & Stapleton: Ferry access, walkable blocks, and ongoing revitalization.
Tompkinsville & Clifton: Emerging pockets with solid upside for buy-and-hold.
Annadale & Great Kills: Suburban feel, strong homeowner pride, stable rents.

Investment Strategies That Work

Buy-and-Hold Multi-Family: Lock in long-term cash flow with 2–4 unit properties.
Live-In + Rent: House-hack a two-family to offset your mortgage.
Renovate for Value: Focus on kitchens, baths, and curb appeal to lift rents and appraisal.

How Mike Helps You Buy Smart

From off-market leads to realistic rent comps, Mike gives you the local edge—so you’re not guessing on numbers or neighborhoods.

Next Step

Ready to run numbers on a real property list? Schedule a consultation today!